Stuff Your Face with Stuffed Cookies!

If you’re not into baking blogs like I am, you may be one of the few who have not yet heard of the hottest new cookie trend on the blogosphere–stuffed cookies.  Yes, they are as deliciously sinful as they sound.  Making stuffed cookies involves making a recipe for a normal cookie dough, and then enclosing a piece of candy, another cookie, or in some crazy case,  S’MORES inside a ball of dough!

The amazing Jenny over at Picky Palate credits herself with making the first ever recipe for stuffed cookies, Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies.  The recipe was an immediate hit, and bloggers started making recipes with their own versions of the rich treats.  Goodies like Brownie Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies, Nutter Butter Stuffed Cookies, and Rolo Stuffed Cookies were popping up all over the internet–and they all looked absolutely delectable.

I am a big fan of baking from scratch, but cookies have never been my forte–they always seem to come out either way too gooey, and sit and get rock hard after a few minutes.  Nonetheless, I decided it did very much want to try and get on the stuffed cookie bandwagon and see what it was all about.

The first recipe I made was the original, Picky Palate’s Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies.  Armed with my shiny new KitchenAid stand mixer, I followed the quite basic cookie dough recipe, and then tried to go about the business of enclosing the Oreos in the cookie dough.  Here is a tip the recipe doesn’t tell you–let your dough chill for at least a good hour before you try to handle it!  It gets warm in your hands very quickly, and you will find it hard to form a ball around the item you are to enclose.  I also made a max of nine cookies per batch, and chilled the dough between batches–this helps a lot.

Through making this recipe, I finally found the perfect time to leave my cookies in the oven.  Eight minutes in my oven was the perfect amount of time for soft, but not too gooey cookies that were still soft and chewy the next day!  And a lesson from my mother finally stuck in my head; take the cookies out when the edges are barely brown, even though the middles look like they are raw.  Cooling time on the pan is very important because it allows the residual heat of the pan to continue baking the cookies to their perfect texture.

This was my first attempt at stuffed cookies:

Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies!

Not too bad right?  They were so yummy!  Quite rich though; one cookie was plenty enough to satisfy my sweet tooth!

I enjoyed these cookies so much, that I decided to try something a little different.  York Peppermint Patties have been one of my favorite candies since I was small, so I knew these Peppermint Patty Cookies I found over at Hugs & Cookies XOXO would not let me down.  And I was right!  They are a perfect balance of chocolate and smooth mint.  I found this dough somewhat softer than the chocolate chip cookie dough, and I decided to let it chill overnight before I made the cookies with it.

Here is how they came out.

York Stuffed Cookies

I love making these cookies so much, and I can’t wait to try more versions!  The most important tips I have for you guys who want to try them are to CHILL THE DOUGH, and DON’T OVERBAKE the cookies.  Take it from me, it is hard to take out the cookies sometimes when they still look raw.  But once you get your technique perfected, I know you will be enjoying this awesome cookie trend as much as I am 🙂

About Carrie

A SAHM who loves her life :)

Posted on August 17, 2011, in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. 8 Comments.

  1. Yum! I want Some!

  2. LOVE THIS!!! THANKS SO MUCH FOR THE SHOUT OUT TOO!!! WOO HOO FOR YORK PEPPERMINT PATTIES!!!! XOXO

  3. YOU DID IT!!! U LINKED UP! I HEART THIS POST!!!!!!!!! XOXO

  4. oh wow these look delectable! My mind is going 90 miles a minute thinking of combos now! I just may have to try these out!

  5. Mmmm…loved this! I can’t wait to try these out.

  6. This is a great one! Baking is definately one of my faves. I thought your first batch, the one with the oreo inside was amazing. I love you and I would like to publically apoligize if I hurt your feelings earlier by saying the wax topic was boring.You totally took it out of context. I didnt mean to hurt your feelings, its just that wax is not my thing. Thats all I meant. Lots of people on here love the subject and I think you should definately keep up the writing.I Personally think you should write a book or work for a newspaper. You could make a fortune with your creativity. Love Mom

  7. Ooo…good idea…love mint!! Thanks for the link love:-)

  1. Pingback: Links I Love « Sweet Southern Home

Leave a Reply to Jen Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: